Matthias, though a relatively quiet figure in the New Testament, plays a significant role in the early Church as the apostle chosen to replace Judas Iscariot. His selection preserved the symbolic number of twelve apostles, representing the twelve tribes of Israel, and emphasized the importance of unity and divine guidance in fulfilling God’s purposes. While little is recorded about Matthias beyond his appointment, his story offers valuable insights into faithfulness, the sovereignty of God, and the cooperative spirit of the early Church.
Words: 1999 / Time to read: 11 minutes
The Selection of Matthias
The appointment of Matthias took place in a critical transitional moment for the disciples, shortly after Jesus’ ascension. As the apostles gathered with about 120 believers in the upper room, Peter addressed the need to replace Judas, whose betrayal of Jesus had left a void among the twelve. Referencing Psalm 69:25 and Psalm 109:8, Peter explained that Scripture foretold the need for another to take Judas’ place (Acts 1:20).
Peter outlined specific criteria for Judas’ replacement: the individual must have been with Jesus throughout His earthly ministry, beginning with His baptism by John and culminating in His ascension, and must be a witness to the resurrection (Acts 1:21-22). This requirement underscored the critical role of the apostles as firsthand witnesses to Christ’s life, death, and resurrection.
Two men were nominated for this important role: Joseph called Barsabbas (also known as Justus) and Matthias. The apostles turned to prayer, asking for God’s guidance:
“Lord, you know everyone’s heart. Show us which of these two you have chosen to take over this apostolic ministry, which Judas left to go where he belongs” (Acts 1:24-25).
After praying, they cast lots, a method often used in biblical times to discern God’s will. The lot fell to Matthias, and he was added to the eleven apostles, completing the group (Acts 1:26). This process demonstrated the apostles’ reliance on God’s sovereignty, seeking His direction in a moment of significant decision-making.
An Excursus on Seeking God’s Will
The selection of Matthias through the casting of lots presents a fascinating intersection of Old Testament practices and the emerging reality of the Church Age. Casting lots was a common method in ancient Israel for discerning God’s will, as seen in Proverbs 16:33:
“The lot is cast into the lap, but its every decision is from the Lord.”
This practice allowed God’s sovereignty to be acknowledged in decisions, ensuring that the outcome was divinely directed. However, it also closely resembled methods of divination used by pagan cultures, which relied on chance to seek supernatural insight. While the Bible permits and even prescribes the casting of lots in certain contexts (Leviticus 16:8-10; Joshua 18:6-10), the distinction lies in its purpose: believers used it to seek God’s guidance in faith, not to manipulate outcomes or predict the future.
The casting of lots is akin to the use of the Urim and Thummim by the high priests of Israel. These sacred tools were employed to determine God’s will in critical matters, functioning as divine instruments in an era when direct access to the Holy Spirit was unavailable. In contrast, during the Church Age, believers no longer rely on external objects or chance-based methods to discern God’s will. Instead, the Holy Spirit provides guidance, conviction, and sanctification to all believers (John 14:26; Galatians 5:16-25).
A Transitional Period
When the apostles selected Matthias, they were in a unique transitional time in salvation history. Jesus had ascended into heaven, but the Holy Spirit had not yet come upon them in the way promised at Pentecost (Acts 2). Without the indwelling presence of the Spirit, the apostles relied on Old Testament practices to make decisions, including the casting of lots.
It is notable that Jesus, in His final instructions before ascending, told His followers to wait in Jerusalem for the coming of the Holy Spirit:
“Do not leave Jerusalem, but wait for the gift my Father promised, which you have heard me speak about. For John baptized with water, but in a few days you will be baptized with the Holy Spirit” (Acts 1:4-5).
While the apostles prayed for guidance, their decision to cast lots may indicate a premature action rather than obedience to Jesus’ directive to wait. If they had waited for the Holy Spirit’s arrival, they might have received direct guidance in choosing Judas’ replacement—or perhaps they would not have selected anyone at all.
In hindsight, we see how God sovereignly guided the Church beyond this moment. Though Matthias was chosen and likely served faithfully, the New Testament does not record his ministry in any detail. By contrast, the Apostle Paul, who was not part of this initial decision, became one of the most prominent figures in spreading the gospel and shaping Christian theology. Paul’s dramatic conversion and divine calling (Acts 9) underscore God’s ability to orchestrate His purposes, even beyond human planning.
The Church Age and the Holy Spirit
With the advent of the Holy Spirit at Pentecost, believers gained unprecedented access to divine guidance. The Spirit’s role in the Church Age includes:
- Baptism of the Spirit: All believers are baptized into the body of Christ, uniting them with Him and each other (1 Corinthians 12:13).
- Guidance and Wisdom: The Holy Spirit leads believers in truth, illuminating God’s Word and helping them make decisions aligned with His will (John 16:13).
- Conviction and Sanctification: The Spirit convicts of sin and empowers believers to live holy lives (John 16:8; Galatians 5:16-25).
- Spiritual Gifts: The Spirit equips believers with gifts to serve the Church and advance the gospel (1 Corinthians 12:7-11).
Because of these benefits, the need for practices like casting lots has ceased. Instead, Christians today discern God’s will through prayer, Scripture, the prompting of the Holy Spirit, and the counsel of trusted believers. Paul reinforces this new reality in Romans 8:14:
“For those who are led by the Spirit of God are the children of God.”
Lessons from Casting Lots
The apostles’ reliance on casting lots to choose Matthias offers both positive and cautionary lessons:
- Trust in God’s Sovereignty: The apostles recognized that God knows every heart and sought His will in their decision. This reliance on divine guidance remains a model for believers today.
- The Importance of Waiting on God: The timing of Matthias’ selection, just before Pentecost, raises questions about whether the apostles should have waited for the Holy Spirit. This underscores the value of patience and obedience when seeking God’s direction.
- A Shift in Divine Guidance: The transition from Old Testament practices to Spirit-led living highlights the unique blessings of the Church Age. Believers today have direct access to God’s guidance through the Holy Spirit, eliminating the need for casting lots or other external methods.
The Role of Matthias and Paul
While Matthias was chosen as the twelfth apostle, his role in the early Church remains largely unrecorded. This silence should not diminish his significance, as faithful service often occurs in obscurity. However, the prominence of Paul in the New Testament suggests that God had additional plans for expanding the apostolic ministry beyond the twelve.
Paul’s calling as an apostle to the Gentiles (Acts 9:15) and his influential writings demonstrate how God can work outside human expectations. In this light, the selection of Matthias serves as a reminder that God’s sovereignty encompasses both our decisions and His ultimate plan.
Modern Implications
For Christians today, the practice of casting lots or similar methods, like laying out fleeces, is unnecessary and potentially harmful. Believers are called to seek God’s will through:
- Prayer: Bringing requests to God with trust in His wisdom (Philippians 4:6).
- Scripture: Allowing God’s Word to shape decisions and actions (2 Timothy 3:16-17).
- Community: Seeking advice from mature believers and spiritual mentors (Proverbs 15:22).
- The Holy Spirit: Being attentive to the Spirit’s conviction, guidance, and peace (Galatians 5:16).
While God used casting lots in biblical times, the coming of the Holy Spirit has provided believers with a more direct and personal relationship with Him. As a result, modern Christians are equipped to discern His will without relying on chance-based methods.
Conclusion of our Excursus
The story of Matthias and the casting of lots highlights a significant transitional moment in the early Church. While it reflects the apostles’ trust in God’s sovereignty, it also underscores the importance of waiting on the Holy Spirit. Today, believers enjoy the unparalleled guidance and empowerment of the Holy Spirit, enabling them to navigate life’s decisions with confidence in God’s leading.
This account serves as a reminder of the blessings of the Church Age and the necessity of seeking God’s will through prayer, Scripture, and Spirit-led discernment. The lesson is clear: rather than relying on external methods, Christians are called to trust in the ever-present guidance of the Holy Spirit, who leads them into all truth.
“For the Spirit God gave us does not make us timid, but gives us power, love and self-discipline” (2 Timothy 1:7).
Matthias’ Role in the Early Church
Though Scripture does not provide further details about Matthias’ ministry, his inclusion among the twelve apostles signifies his participation in the foundational work of the early Church. As a witness to Jesus’ resurrection, Matthias would have shared in the mission of preaching the gospel, teaching new believers, and building the Church.
It is likely that Matthias was present at Pentecost when the Holy Spirit descended upon the apostles, empowering them to proclaim the message of salvation to people from diverse nations and languages (Acts 2:1-4). Extra-biblical tradition suggests that Matthias ministered in Judea and possibly traveled to other regions, faithfully carrying out his apostolic calling.
Matthias’ story exemplifies the quiet yet steadfast faithfulness required to serve God effectively. Unlike Peter or Paul, whose ministries are well-documented in the New Testament, Matthias served without seeking prominence or recognition. His life reminds believers that the advancement of God’s kingdom often depends on the faithfulness of those who humbly fulfill the roles to which they are called.
Lessons from Matthias’ Life
Matthias’ story, though brief, offers several important lessons for believers:
- Faithfulness in Obscurity
Matthias reminds us that God values faithfulness over recognition. Though his ministry is not detailed in Scripture, his inclusion among the twelve affirms that quiet, steadfast service is vital to God’s kingdom. - The Sovereignty of God in Calling
The casting of lots to select Matthias illustrates the Church’s reliance on God’s guidance in critical decisions. It serves as a reminder that God knows the hearts of His people and directs them according to His will. - The Importance of Being a Witness
Matthias’ qualification as a witness to Jesus’ resurrection highlights the central role of testifying to Christ’s life, death, and victory over sin and death. Believers today are called to continue this witness, sharing the gospel with the world. - Unity in the Church
The apostles’ collective decision-making process reflects the unity of the early Church. Matthias’ appointment serves as a model for seeking God’s will in harmony with other believers, fostering collaboration in fulfilling His purposes.
Conclusion
Matthias, though a quiet figure in the New Testament, played a crucial role in the early Church as the apostle chosen to restore the twelve. His selection demonstrates the sovereignty of God and the importance of unity, faithfulness, and reliance on divine guidance. Matthias’ life reminds believers that God’s kingdom is built not only by prominent leaders but also by those who humbly and obediently serve in the roles to which they are called. His inclusion among the twelve apostles testifies to God’s faithfulness in equipping and using His people to advance His eternal purposes.
“Then they prayed, ‘Lord, you know everyone’s heart. Show us which of these two you have chosen to take over this apostolic ministry, which Judas left to go where he belongs.’ Then they cast lots, and the lot fell to Matthias; so he was added to the eleven apostles (Acts 1:24-26).”
All Scripture quoted from:
New International Version (NIV)
Holy Bible, New International Version®, NIV® Copyright ©1973, 1978, 1984, 2011 by Biblica, Inc.® Used by permission. All rights reserved worldwide.
