The Bible is the most influential book in history, revered by millions as the inspired Word of God. Yet, few consider how this sacred collection of texts came to be. The process of recognizing, collecting, and canonizing the books of the Bible was long and arduous, involving centuries of debate, councils, and theological struggles. Unlike the prophets and apostles who penned these writings under divine inspiration, those who determined the final form of the biblical canon were fallible men—church leaders, scholars, and political figures—some of whom we know little about and some who may not have even been true believers. Despite human imperfections, the Holy Spirit sovereignly guided this process, ensuring that God’s intended Word was preserved through the hands of imperfect individuals. Understanding the canonization process helps us appreciate not only the authority of Scripture but also the divine providence that ensured we have the Bible exactly as God intended.
Words: 1149 / Time to read: 6 minutes
The Writing of the Scriptures and the Need for Canonization
The Old Testament, also known as the Hebrew Bible, was written over a period of about 1,000 years, from approximately 1400 BC to 400 BC. The books were originally recorded in Hebrew, with some sections in Aramaic. These texts formed the foundation of Jewish religious life, carefully preserved by scribes. However, by the time of Jesus, various Jewish sects debated the boundaries of their sacred writings. While the Pharisees recognized a broader canon resembling today’s Old Testament, the Sadducees only accepted the Torah (the first five books). The Septuagint (LXX), a Greek translation of Jewish Scriptures, included additional writings that later became the Deuterocanonical books in Catholic Bibles.
The New Testament, written between 45–95 AD, was composed by apostles and early Christian leaders. However, unlike the Old Testament, which had centuries to develop, the Christian Scriptures were compiled within a much shorter time. By the end of the first century, many churches used collections of apostolic writings, but disagreements arose regarding which texts should be considered authoritative. The need to establish a definitive canon became more urgent as heresies, forgeries, and rival religious movements emerged in the early centuries of Christianity.
The Process of Canonization: Who Decided and When?
The process of canonization was not immediate, nor was it conducted by a single authority at one time. Instead, the canon developed gradually through the decisions of various councils, church fathers, and regional synods over centuries. Several key milestones in the establishment of the biblical canon include:
- The Muratorian Fragment (c. 170 AD) – One of the earliest known lists of New Testament books, though it differs slightly from today’s canon.
- Origen (c. 185–253 AD) and Eusebius (c. 260–339 AD) – Early church historians who categorized books as universally accepted, disputed, or outright rejected.
- The Synod of Hippo (393 AD) and Councils of Carthage (397 & 419 AD) – These councils, led by early Latin Church leaders such as Augustine, affirmed the 27-book New Testament canon.
- The Council of Rome (382 AD) – Under Pope Damasus I, a canon resembling today’s Catholic Bible was recognized.
- The Council of Trent (1546 AD) – In response to the Protestant Reformation, the Catholic Church formally affirmed the inclusion of the Deuterocanonical books.
Unlike the New Testament, which had clearer boundaries set by the time of these councils, the Old Testament canon remained debated. The Jewish community ultimately settled on a 39-book Hebrew Bible (Masoretic Text) around 90 AD at the Council of Jamnia, rejecting the Deuterocanonical books that the early Christians continued to use.
The Role of Fallible Human Beings in Canonization
While Christians believe the Bible is divinely inspired, the historical reality is that its official recognition was determined by human decision-making. The individuals responsible for defining the canon were not prophets or apostles but later church leaders, theologians, and even emperors—many of whom were engaged in political struggles or theological disputes.
For example, Emperor Constantine played a significant role in the formalization of Christianity and its texts, even commissioning 50 copies of the Bible in the early 4th century. Some scholars argue that his involvement had political motives as much as theological ones. Others who shaped the canon, such as Jerome (translator of the Latin Vulgate), made editorial choices and theological judgments that influenced which books were considered authoritative.
Furthermore, many scribes and scholars who copied and transmitted biblical texts over the centuries were not necessarily Christian. The Masoretic scribes who preserved the Hebrew Bible were Jewish scholars who rejected the New Testament. Medieval copyists included both faithful monks and secular scribes who may not have shared Christian beliefs but were skilled in manuscript preservation.
God’s Sovereignty in the Canonization Process
Despite the fallibility of those involved, Christians can have confidence that God sovereignly guided the canonization process. Just as He inspired the prophets and apostles to write the Scriptures, He also worked through councils, scribes, and scholars—many with imperfect motives—to preserve His Word exactly as He intended. Human leaders may have debated, delayed, and disagreed, but ultimately, the Holy Spirit ensured that the right books were recognized and preserved for future generations.
Even when political and doctrinal disputes influenced the process, God was not absent. He used fallible individuals to accomplish His divine will, just as He has throughout history. The Bible is not merely the result of human decision-making—it is the divinely preserved record of God’s revelation to humanity. Despite centuries of challenges, disputes, and textual variations, the core message of the Bible remains unchanged: God’s plan for redemption through Jesus Christ.
Conclusion: Trusting the Canon Despite Its Complex History
The Bible did not descend from heaven in a finalized form but was compiled, edited, and canonized over centuries by fallible human beings. While believers trust in divine inspiration, history reminds us that the establishment of the canon was a long and tedious process shaped by councils, theological debates, and the decisions of individuals—some of whom we know little about and some of whom may not have even been Christians.
Yet, despite its complex human history, the canon has endured. Whether through the early councils of the Church, the work of scholars, or the preservation efforts of monks and scribes, the sacred texts have been carefully maintained and passed down to future generations. For Christians, this endurance is evidence of God’s sovereign hand guiding the process. The Bible’s existence today is not merely the result of theological consensus but a testimony to divine preservation through the hands of imperfect men.
Matthew 24:35 – “Heaven and earth will pass away, but my words will never pass away.”
All Scripture quoted from:
New International Version (NIV)
Holy Bible, New International Version®, NIV® Copyright ©1973, 1978, 1984, 2011 by Biblica, Inc.® Used by permission. All rights reserved worldwide.